Get Quote Team Become a Dealer

Buyer Guide

Wheeled vs Tracked Skid Steer: Same Rated Load, Different Machine

HLY100 vs HLT100 at 1,200 kg rated load: tracks add 950 kg; hydraulics, speed and bucket are the same. Ground pressure, sizes and when each pays off.

Wheeled vs tracked skid steer loader compared at the same rated load

By Avicii Meng, Head of Technical Engineering, HONGLI Machinery

Most wheeled-vs-tracked guides compare generic machines. This one compares pairs from our own range that carry the same rated load, so the only real difference is the undercarriage. At 1,200 kg, the wheeled HLY100 and the tracked HLT100 publish the same bucket, hydraulic flow, travel speed and height. The tracked machine weighs 950 kg more and is 150 mm wider. At 700 kg, the pair is the wheeled HLY45 and the tracked HLT50. Already know which one you need? Request an HLY100 quote or request an HLT100 quote.

The short answer

Choose tracks when the ground is soft, wet, loose or must not be rutted. Choose wheels when the ground is firm and you want the lighter, narrower machine. At 1,200 kg, our two machines are equally capable once they have traction. You are choosing the undercarriage, not the loader.

1,200 kg class: HLY100 vs HLT100

Specification HLY100 (wheeled) HLT100 (tracked)
Rated operating capacity 1,200 kg 1,200 kg
Tipping load 2,400 kg 2,400 kg
Operating weight 3,550 kg 4,500 kg
Bucket capacity 0.55 m³ 0.55 m³
Hydraulic flow, standard / high-flow 80 / 140 L/min 80 / 140 L/min
Max travel speed 12 / 18 km/h 12 / 18 km/h
Height to boom pivot pin 3,150 mm 3,150 mm
Overall height 2,160 mm 2,160 mm
Length with bucket 3,580 mm 3,700 mm
Width with bucket 1,880 mm 2,030 mm
Fuel tank 90 L 90 L
Running gear 12-16.5 tyres, 1,115 mm wheelbase, 205 mm ground clearance 320 mm tracks, 1,500 mm ground contact length

What the table shows:

  • Same work rate on firm ground. Bucket, both hydraulic circuits and travel speed are identical, so attachments that need 140 L/min high flow run on either machine.
  • Tracks cost weight and width. The HLT100 is 950 kg heavier (about 27% more than the HLY100), 150 mm wider and 120 mm longer with the bucket. Plan for that in trailer payload, gate widths and container loading.
  • Rating basis. Both rated loads are 50% of the tipping load (1,200 of 2,400 kg). Some compact track loader spec sheets also quote a 35% figure; on that basis the HLT100 would rate 840 kg. If your market or tender specifies a basis, tell us when you request a quote.

700 kg class: HLY45 vs HLT50

Specification HLY45 (wheeled) HLT50 (tracked)
Rated operating capacity 700 kg 700 kg
Tipping load 1,400 kg Not published
Bucket capacity 0.4 m³ 0.4 m³
Rated hydraulic flow 75 L/min (no high-flow) 80 L/min
Max travel speed 12 km/h 10 km/h
Length with bucket 3,420 mm 3,150 mm
Fuel tank 65 L 50 L
Weight as published 3,100 kg operating weight 2,800 kg unladen; 3,224 kg with bucket
Running gear 10-16.5 tyres, 991 mm wheelbase, 185 mm ground clearance 300 mm tracks (300 × 52.5)

At this size the trade-off is different. The wheeled HLY45 is the faster machine (12 vs 10 km/h) and carries a larger fuel tank. The tracked HLT50 is 270 mm shorter with the bucket, which helps in tight yards and on small sites. The two weight figures are published on different bases, so we do not compare them here.

Ground pressure: the number that decides it

Ground pressure is the machine’s weight divided by the area in contact with the ground. For the HLT100:

  • Contact area: 2 tracks × 0.32 m wide × 1.5 m ground contact length = 0.96 m²
  • Weight: 4,500 kg × 9.81 m/s² ≈ 44.1 kN
  • Nominal ground pressure: 44.1 kN ÷ 0.96 m² ≈ 46 kPa (about 6.7 psi)

This is a nominal, static figure. It assumes an empty bucket and the full track length flat on the ground. A loaded bucket adds weight, and real pressure peaks under the rollers. Even so, it is the right number for comparing machines on soft ground.

A tyre’s contact pressure depends on its inflation pressure and load, so it varies with tyre choice and how the tyres are set up. If soft ground is your main concern, ask us for the tyre options and inflation figures for the HLY range alongside the HLT figures above.

When the wheeled HLY range is the better buy

  • Firm, paved or dry ground: yards, warehouses, farms with hardstanding, roadwork.
  • Transport and access matter: at 1,200 kg the HLY100 is 950 kg lighter and 150 mm narrower than the HLT100.
  • Smaller machines: HLY models start at 300 kg rated load, and the tracked range starts at 700 kg.
  • At 700 kg, you want more speed (12 km/h) and a bigger fuel tank.

When the tracked HLT range is the better buy

  • Soft, wet, muddy, sandy or freshly graded ground, where tyres would dig in.
  • Turf and finished surfaces that must not be rutted.
  • Slopes and loose material, where a long track footprint keeps traction.
  • At 700 kg, you need the shorter machine (3,150 mm with bucket).

Tyres and rubber tracks are both wear parts. Ask for replacement prices in the same quote, so you compare running costs rather than purchase price alone.

Five questions to answer before you order

  1. What is the softest ground the machine will work on, and for how much of the year?
  2. Which attachments will it run? Check their hydraulic flow against 75, 80 or 140 L/min.
  3. How will it travel between sites: trailer payload, width limits, container loading?
  4. Which rating basis does your market or tender use: 35% or 50% of tipping load?
  5. Which ports and Incoterms do you need priced?

FAQ

Is a tracked skid steer more capable than a wheeled one?

Not on firm ground. Our HLY100 and HLT100 publish the same rated load, tipping load, bucket, hydraulic flow and travel speed. Tracks earn their extra weight on soft or loose ground.

What is the ground pressure of a tracked skid steer?

For our HLT100, the nominal static figure is about 46 kPa (6.7 psi), calculated above from its 4,500 kg operating weight and 0.96 m² of track contact.

Can both machines run high-flow attachments?

At 1,200 kg, yes: both the HLY100 and the HLT100 offer 140 L/min high flow. The 700 kg HLY45 has no high-flow circuit.

Is the HLY a wheel loader?

No. The HLY is a wheeled skid-steer loader: it steers by driving each side at different speeds, not by articulating like a wheel loader.

What sizes does HONGLI build?

Wheeled HLY models from 300 to 1,500 kg rated load, and tracked HLT models from 700 to 1,500 kg.

Related: wheeled skid-steer loaders · tracked skid-steer loaders · Skid Steer vs Wheel Loader · request a quotation

Get a Quote · Chat on WhatsApp · Download Catalog (PDF)